David vs David

I've vacillated back and forth between these two.  I thought D. Cook could have done better and know he's capable of it.  I've adored D. Archuleta from the get go but I have to admit I'm getting a bit tired of his "humble" Thank you's. It's like he has to put effort into being deeply sincere.  Not that he isn't it's just that it seems a little fake because he's heard time and time again. I think Cook has more charisma for the stage and an audience where as Archuleta is so young yet. 

I've thought all along that Archuleta was going to win it but that Cook should be the winner.  I was going to change my stance on that until I watched the performances last night.  So I still feel the same. Archuleta will win it but Cook should be the Next American Idol.